Power Transformers Blog – Expert Safety and Usage Info

An Electrical Contractor called MIDWEST with an emergency. A customer lost a 1500 kva dry type power transformer. The voltage was 13,200 to 480.  Two of the fuses in the primary load break switch had blown. They checked things out and couldn’t find anything wrong, but wanted MIDWEST to test the transformer anyway. Meanwhile they checked out the secondary switchgear and a 480 volt to 208 volt dry type transformer in the same room as the switchgear. They found no smell and no smoke, so they figured they might get lucky, although we both knew that was not very probably.  When 15kv, 100 amp fuses blow, a lot of energy went somewhere.  The 1500 kva dry type transformer was a typical indoor unit substation type, with LAs, cooling fans and a fan control package. When we got there, the electrical contractor already had the panels off the switchgear and transformer, and everything properly grounded.  They offered to help haul up the test equipment, which is always nice, but we said to hold off for a minute.  It took 15 seconds to get our flashlight and then it took another 15 seconds to inspect the transformer and tell them the transformer had failed and they needed to get a replacement transformer or a rental transformer. Their skepticism was obvious, and for good reason. But we showed them the debris that had blown out the bottom of the center high voltage winding. Then had them look down through ventilation ports of the blown high voltage winding so they could see the blown out turns within the high voltage winding.  They understood immediately.  We ran a quick turns ratio test to document the failure. A case of seeing is believing.

Power Transformers Defect at Top of Winding

MIDWEST frequently rejects equipment even thought it passes the electrical tests. Here’s an obvious example. MIDWEST’s Switchgear Shop rejected a 225 kva 480 volt delta to 480/277 volt wye dry type electrical transformer. We only had the core and coils, not the enclosure. The insulation resistance, winding resistance, and turns ration test results were all good. The transformer was energized at full primary voltage and had proper secondary voltage for the tap position. This all sounds good. So, why was the transformer classified scrap junk?  An inspection revealed the top two turns of the primary windings of one barrel had been crushed down. Something had been dropped onto these winding turns and pushed them down and separated them. The damage wasn’t physically dramatic. It was almost inconspicuous. But it was fatal to the transformer. In addition, this damage didn’t appear to have caused the fault that blew the fuses that resulted in the owner sending us the transformer to check it out. But we also found one of the ‘unused’ tap tabs was melted off to the point the bolt hole was completely gone. The end of the tab looked very clean. The transformer was connected in a different tap. On top of all this, the side of the winding seemed blackened by an apparent arc blast. Apparently the bolted connection at this tap became loose and the arcing completely destroyed the tap connection. The taps of the transformer were changed in an effort to restore power until a replacement transformer was installed. Sometimes the physical damage to electrical power transformers is very obvious. In this case, the damage to the electrical transformer was not as obvious as one might think.  At least until after it was found. Test results alone can not be used to evaluate the condition of electrical dry type power transformers. The transformer must also be thoroughly inspected. What MIDWEST calls a ‘hard focus’ inspection.

MIDWEST was called to check out an old 3750 kva oil filled transformer. The owner was trying to decide whether to reclaim the oil in the old power transformer or to go ahead and replace it with a new 5000 Kva transformer. They actually needed a 5 Mva replacement power transformer. They had the history of the oil test results. It was apparent the transformer had slowly absorbed moisture over the years and there was serious paper degredation. They wanted MIDWEST to do an under the cover inspection to see if there were visual signs of sludge and tank rust. Pretty straight forward stuff. Their electricians asked if they could look inside the transformer while we had the access cover open. They had to follow our safety precautions.  They were absolutely amazed to see all the wood used inside the transformer. Almost the entire top of the core and coils was hidden under wood.  The wood was used for blocking, for support of the tap changer, and for making the high voltage connects going to the line side of the windings. The electricians were a little skeptical when we explained how much wood was actually used in transformer construction. How common it was. And that 15 Kv high voltage terminations were made on the wood. They were also surprised how clean the inside of the transformer looked, even though the oil was dark and there was visible sludge on flat surfaces, especially on the wood. For the electricians, seeing was believing. High voltage oil filled power transformers are made with wood.

This MIDWEST blog is about a low voltage, high current transformer used in a hardening process. The transformer was physically located deep in the process equipment. It was very difficult for the owner to access the transformer for maintenance. They just could not maintain it during normal production schedules. The process operators were having more and more trouble controlling the output voltage and current. It got to the point they just could no longer regulated the output current as necessary to perform the metal hardening process. MIDWEST was contracted to remove and replace the transformer or repair it. Whatever could be done. When the transformer was being removed, the problem was found immediately.  There were massive copper bus bars on the secondary side of the transformer to carry the high currents. One of the output bus bar bolted connections had failed. It was held by only four bolts and the bolted connection had become loose. The copper at the connection was discolored and distorted from overheating. The connection contact surfaces were all destroyed by being overheated.  The damaged copper and damaged connection contact surfaces for this damaged transformer could not be repaired. The copper was damaged all the way into the winding. All the other connections were intact. The repair bill was over $50,000.00. This four bolt connection cost over $12,000.00 per bolt to repair.  The transformer replacement was not caused by a transformer failure, but by a simple bolted connection failure. MIDWEST frequently finds dry type transformer failures or replacement transformer projects are caused by the most probable failure mode because the needed preventive maintenance was not performed, because it would have been relatively expensive compared to routine, specified, maintenance. Everyone understands the value of the maintenance dollar. But it does not make sense to continually spend hard to get maintenance dollars on preventing very low probability failure modes and totally ignore the most probably failure mode all together, when the most probable mode would be catastrophic and the low probability failure modes have little consequence.  This is a nightmare for maintenance supervisors. It can be tough to sell critical maintenance procedures that are not found in standard maintenance specifications.

MIDWEST works a lot with electricians, maintenance mechanics, and other assorted electrical folks that have the every day job of keeping production machines running. When they call for help, for example when they suddenly need a replacement transformer, they want the short answer to their question. Sometimes you can tell from the edge in their voice that they are overwhelmed, in a real jam, and, if we put more burden on them by asking twenty questions about their old transformers, they are just going to stop listening, say thank you, and hang up. They want an immediate short answer to their immediate question.  This isn’t always possible or safe, but, since we have so much field service experience, we usually can get to the point quickly.

Sometimes the simplicity of the request can be amazing. For example, we had an electrician call during his lunch break and ask how he could tell if one of their old dry type transformers, used for production machines, was overheating. They had added a ton of equipment to it over recent years and he was worried the transformer was overloaded and would fail. His boss knew nothing about old, new, replacement electrical transformers and really didn’t want to be bothered with a “maybe problem.” The electrician needed something to get his bosses attention. He couldn’t measure the load, but he just knew it was overloaded.

Our unscientific suggestion was to put his hand on the top of the old power transformer enclosure. If he couldn’t hold it there for a few seconds, the transformer is in danger of being overloaded. The load should be measured and compared to the nameplate rating. If they don’t, they run the risk of the transformer failing when they least expect it, say the day before a holiday. Getting and installing a replacement transformer under emergency conditions can be a lot more expensive than scheduled transformer replacement. You don’t want to get burned.

Safety note. Be sure the transformer is grounded before touching it.

MIDWEST is frequently asked about some of our unusual experiences over the years.  Things that happened that had no text book solution. Here is one of those experiences, having to do with an old outdoor askarel (PCB) filled transformer. The transformer was a transplant from indoor to outdoor. A little crazy, even in those days. This happened decades ago. Back when old askarel transformers were still sampled.  The fluid dielectric strength test results were horrible, 14 Kv. During their next plant shutdown, we inspected the transformer and found about 4” of water layered and floating on top of the askarel fluid. Askarel fluid weighed about 12.7 lbs. per gallon, so the lighter water, about 8 lbs per gallon, just mostly floated on the top of the dielectric fluid, askarel. The exposed glass rupture disk on top of the old power transformer had cracked when rained turned to ice during the winter. The internal high voltage (13,800 volts) leads, from the high voltage bushings to the transformer windings, actually passed through the layer of water. These leads were insulated, but not insulated against water. The secondary bushing leads were below the free water level.  The plant would be in crisis without this transformer. They had no spare replacement transformer. It would take too long to get a reconditioned, rebuilt or new transformer. So the plant engineer said, “It was working when we turned it off, so, when you’re done, we’re turning it back on.”  We removed the layer of free water; Added R-Temp Transformer Fluid to the proper level; Turned the transformer back on; and no noise, good. All the PCB contaminated fluid and debris was properly disposed at an EPA authorized facility. 

MIDWEST told the customer the transformer needed to be replaced as soon as possible.  There was an incipient, even imminent, failure.  The next time we heard from the customer was seven months later when the 1000 kva transformer failed.  Our advice was ignored. But we were amazed the transformer lasted that long.

Here is another MIDWEST transformer horror story.  This involves a 1000 kva indoor dry type power transformer, 13.2 Kv to 120/208 volts.  The first time we saw this transformer, we thought it was just a spare new transformer core and coil being stored in one of the customer’s equipment rooms. It looked just like a replacement transformer because the core and coil were not in a metal enclosure.  It was out in the wide open area of the room with no protective enclosure or barriers, nothing to protect it. To our great surprise, we soon realized that this old transformer was energized.  The hmmm and the exposed wires connected to it were a big tip. One had to walk around the transformer to get to one corner of the room.  Beside electrical conduits, there were other overhead pipes in the room, plus communication cables.  There were electrical panels and non electrical equipment in the room.  The electrician said he was told it was okay because it was a locked door and nobody was suppose to go in there.  He told his boss that he thought it was very dangerous, but he was told it met code. He thought the whole thing was nuts. We asked where the key was secured so that unqualified personnel could not enter the room, which they called a vault. The key was hung on a nail over a nearby doorway going into a mechanical equipment room. This was considered secure because nobody knew what the key was for, except the ‘right’ people.  We explained the extreme shock hazard and arc flash hazard to anyone, even qualified personnel, entering the room and the fact that unqualified personnel may acquire access to the room because of the key location.  In plain English, this set up was crazy.  To this day, nothing may have changed, because someone decreed “it met code.”